Reading · easy

Based on the text, which statement best explains how the findings at Pattanam challenge previous historical conclusions?

Many Hellenistic-era glass artifacts discovered in South Asia were made using plant-ash fluxes rather than mineral natron, a flux characteristic of Mediterranean manufacturing. Because Mediterranean workshops in Egypt and the Levant relied almost exclusively on natron, some historians concluded that South Asian communities maintained little to no exchange with Mediterranean glassmakers during the third century BCE. However, recent excavations at Pattanam in southwestern India uncovered glassworking crucibles containing residue of natron-rich glass slag alongside native quartz sands. Rather than importing finished Western glass vessels, South Asian artisans appear to have imported raw natron glass ingots, which they then melted and blended with local materials to produce regional wares.

Based on the text, which statement best explains how the findings at Pattanam challenge previous historical conclusions?

Answer & explanation

Correct answer: B. They indicate that South Asian artisans had trade connections with Mediterranean glassmakers despite the rarity of imported finished glassware.

The passage explains that historians previously inferred a lack of contact between South Asian communities and Mediterranean glassmakers because South Asian artifacts featured plant-ash flux instead of Mediterranean natron flux. However, the crucibles at Pattanam contain natron slag mixed with local quartz, suggesting that South Asian artisans imported raw natron glass ingots from the Mediterranean to rework locally. Thus, the findings challenge the earlier view by showing that commercial links with Mediterranean producers did exist, even though finished Mediterranean glass vessels were not commonly imported.

Choice A fails because the text describes Mediterranean natron glass entering South Asia, not Mediterranean artisans importing plant-ash flux.

Choice C fails because the text links natron to Mediterranean imports, not the discovery of local natron deposits.

Choice D fails because the text notes that raw ingots were imported rather than finished vessels.

Practice 10 questions free Today’s question of the day

Based on the text, which statement best explains how the findings at Pattanam challenge previous historical conclusions?

Based on the text, which statement best explains how the findings at Pattanam challenge previous historical conclusions?

Answer & explanation

More Reading practice questions